Wednesday, May 09, 2007

Ranting about Rant

We're going to see Chuck Palahniuk on Thursday. It's really exciting because our city doesn't seem to have a literary pulse, and authors, especially authors that we like, rarely come to visit.

While I have not had the chance to read Palahniuk's new book, I'm excited to finally "meet" him. The last time he was in town, I was a college freshman who had no idea who he was and therefore passed up the opportunity that I regretted for years after.

I want to read his new book Rant: An Oral Biography of Buster Casey before the signing, but seeing as how it's a day away, I don't think it's going to happen. However, I did have a chance to read the reviews on Amazon. Stranded amongst the generally benevolent 4-5 star reviews, was this little review, posted on May 9th by Mr. Joseph Suglia (novelist) attacking Palahniuk's novel with the same sort of vim and vigor that people in the 14th century use to display when they lobbed fruit and vegetables at the village idiot. Since I haven't read the book, there's nothing much I can say in terms of his general evaluation of it's merits. I do, however, have a problem with his attack on Palahniuk's readership.


The sub-normal high-school stoners who comprise much of Palahniuk's massive`fan-base' will find the book more boring than the most boring documentary on rabies.


Ouch, that's harsh. Makes me feel like I should crawl back into the sewer that I was born out of for one thing.

On a serious note, I am absolutely sure that there are plenty of teenagers who love Palahniuk, and feel that his books are angsty anthems to their lives. But just because Palahniuk appeals to them doesn't mean that his work is invalid or that these 'sub-normal high-school stoners' don't have the intelligence to see the merit in his work. Secondly, sub-normal is inappropriate. I am so glad that Mr. Suglia had a normal and wonderful high school life. But I am really sick of 'normal' people making snap judgements about people that they don't understand or know.

I understand the statement was meant to be sarcastic and condescending, but it's disheartening to see one writer degrade another based on the supposed sub-normality of his fan-base.

**Update: Interestingly enough, when I checked Amazon today (May 11, 2007) Mr. Suglia had removed his review.

9 comments:

Joseph Suglia said...

You're only making my point.

CChen said...

We're all entitled to an opinion, Mr. Suglia. And I would have a higher opinion of you if you had written something intelligent to defend your review instead of resorting to petty name-calling.

But then again, you can't feel you had much of a point since you deleted your review.

Hope you have a great career!

Anonymous said...

To win in the Online blackjack a chronic narrative based bonus slot plot unified so that each bonus daily round is dissimilar. [url=http://www.onlinecasinoburger.co.uk/]uk online casino[/url] online casino This can be an option to Deal when Well-chosen botting! http://www.tasty-onlinecasino.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

Most of the time, these types of review web sites also offer an index of suggested internet vendors as well [url=http://www.nywgi.co.uk/]cash loans[/url] cash loans However right now we have find out the solution to almost all their problems http://www.pdtji.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

Just make sure you're more than capable of paying back the debt so you tend not to run into issues and accept you are forking over more than you should have to or else [url=http://www.lobjy.co.uk/]same day loans[/url] same day loans uk If you don"t pay back your debt, the provider will keep the v5 document once and for all and you will get rid of your car in addition http://www.lobjy.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

I don't want to bulk up too much, so I lift for about Half an hour [url=http://www.abkhl.co.uk/]http://www.loansinstantpaydaynow.co.uk/[/url] http://www.loansinstantpaydaynow.co.uk/ One of the best solutions to do this is usually to refinance school loans http://www.abkhl.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

Most lenders today will probably limit where one can purchase a vehicle [url=http://www.ssrpaydayloansuk.co.uk/]http://www.ssrpaydayloansuk.co.uk/[/url] pay day loans uk Makes a Wonderful Gift http://www.arfar.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

These financial schemes may be used for satisfying short term needs and requirements by way of example unpredicted vehicle repair expenditures, electricity bills, store bills, child's school or maybe tuition fees, weekend trip tours as well as pay off a person's credit card subscribers [url=http://www.paydayfreakuk.co.uk/]payday loans[/url] payday loans uk Concerning repayment, you ought to pay back loan within Three to five weeks http://www.paydayweirdo.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

freeways, just now streets radiating out on the antediluvian, straggly street plan Outlined by the centuries. [url=http://www.nabetaxi.com/cgi/bbs/keiziban.cgi]More Bonuses[/url] Read This As it does so the pee warms http://milanation.com/shop/thread-michelle-strapless-dress-with-rosettes/#comment-53484